Ask the person with the diagnosis how things are going and the answer is often that things are going fine. Ask the person who does their shopping, their washing and their worrying, and you get a different account of the same week. That gap is the subject of a study published in BMC Geriatrics on 22 December 2025 by Hester Fidder and colleagues at Amsterdam UMC's department of Medicine for Older People, and it is the most ordinary and most exhausting fact of many caregiving lives. The team carried out 28 in-depth, semi-structured interviews with 14 dyads: a person living with dementia (Alzheimer's disease, including mixed Alzheimer's and vascular), Huntington's disease or Korsakoff's syndrome, all of whom had impaired awareness, together with their informal caregiver. The interviews covered awareness of the diagnosis itself, of physical and cognitive functioning, of social and behavioural functioning, and of risk in everyday activities. This is qualitative work, describing experience rather than counting it, and the researchers analysed it with inductive thematic content analysis.
What came out was four connected themes: how impaired awareness gets expressed by the person, how caregivers read it, how caregivers respond to it, and what follows from it. The headline result is a mismatch that families will recognise instantly. In general, the people with dementia, Huntington's or Korsakoff's reported no problems arising from their impaired awareness. Their caregivers described substantial challenges. The consequences the authors recorded, mostly from the caregivers' side of the interview, included refusal of help with activities of daily living, engagement in risky behaviour, and conflict and frustration inside the pair. Notably, the authors point out that before this study no qualitative research had specifically explored impaired awareness in Huntington's disease or in Korsakoff's syndrome; the literature had been almost entirely about Alzheimer's.
For Korsakoff families, the comparative finding is the one to sit with. The team looked for experiences that belonged to one condition and not the others, and reported that despite wide variation between individuals and between domains of functioning, they observed no experiences specific to any disease group. In other words, the disputed memory, the insistence that help is not needed, the flat contradiction of what a partner saw with their own eyes: none of it emerged as uniquely Korsakoff, or uniquely Huntington's, or uniquely Alzheimer's, in this sample. Three very different mechanisms, one neurodegenerative, one genetic, one caused by thiamine deficiency, produced daily lives that looked recognisably alike to the people living them. With 14 pairs, that is an absence of evidence for difference rather than proof of sameness, and the authors frame it as such.
The scale of impaired awareness in Korsakoff's has been measured elsewhere by the same Dutch research network. A cross-sectional study by Ineke Gerridzen and colleagues, published in the International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry in 2019, assessed 215 residents with Korsakoff syndrome or other alcohol-related cognitive disorders living in specialised nursing homes using the Patient Competency Rating Scale, comparing self-ratings against staff ratings. Twenty-nine percent had no or mildly impaired awareness, 37 percent were moderately impaired and 34 percent severely impaired. A later cross-sectional study of 281 residents across nine specialised Dutch nursing homes, published in the Journal of Clinical Medicine on 11 March 2023, found impaired awareness statistically associated with dependence in activities of daily living (odds ratio 4.25, 95 percent confidence interval 1.56 to 12.32). That is an association measured at a single point in time, not a demonstration that unawareness causes dependence.
So, correct or let it stand? The Amsterdam UMC paper does not answer that, and it does not pretend to. Its conclusion is narrower and more useful than a rule: education about impaired awareness, and about managing its consequences, may benefit caregivers and improve care. A separate piece of work points the same way. A stakeholder consultation on lack of awareness in dementia by Catherine Alexander and Linda Clare at the University of Exeter, published in Frontiers in Dementia on 12 February 2026, reported that management involved a flexible and patient approach, avoiding confrontation where possible, and observed that there is no indication that forcing acknowledgement of symptoms or of the diagnosis helps the individual. Neither study tested one strategy against another, and neither replaces the judgement of the clinician who knows the household.