Grace is 87. In an online survey run by researchers at Charles Sturt University, she typed a sentence that reads less like a research response than a correction of the record: "Having dementia, as I understand it, does not mean that I am unable to make rational decisions." She went on to say that people living with dementia have feelings and should have the right to choose the timing of their own death. Dolores, 76, wanted control over her life and her death as far as that is possible. Harold, 70, made the argument that runs underneath all of it: that shutting people out of assisted dying because of a dementia diagnosis is discrimination, and that what is needed is better support to decide, not a closed door.

The survey those quotes come from was published in the Cambridge University Press journal Ageing and Society, online on 24 September 2025, by Adrienne Matthys, Belinda Cash and Bernadette Moorhead. Thirty-six Australians living with dementia self-selected into it. The paper reports that the vast majority wanted the option of voluntary assisted dying for themselves. It is a small, self-selected, cross-sectional survey, and the authors designed it that way on purpose: their earlier scoping review, published in the Australasian Journal on Ageing on 9 September 2024, had found that Australians living with dementia were largely absent from the research literature on voluntary assisted dying, a debate conducted about them by clinicians, families, lawyers and pollsters. The survey was an attempt to end that absence by asking the people themselves.

In a researcher-authored account published in late September 2026 in The Conversation and reprinted by Aged Care Insite, the same team describes a second, follow-up study: interviews with 12 people drawn from the survey group, to understand why the preference was so strong. What they describe is not an abstraction about autonomy. It is fear with a specific shape. Clara, 76, said that since moving into care and seeing people whose dementia was far more advanced, she could see no quality of life there, and did not want that future for herself. Others spoke of losing continence, of poor residential care, of the possibility of abuse. The researchers report that many participants also believed their end-of-life choices were already being discounted, influenced by dated assumptions about their capacity rather than by any assessment of what they could actually decide.

What these studies are not is a clinical finding. Nobody measured capacity here. Nobody tested whether a person in the moderate or advanced stages of a dementia could satisfy the legal thresholds that voluntary assisted dying laws set, and nobody followed participants forward to see whether their stated preference held as their condition changed. Under Australian law as the authors describe it, people living with dementia cannot choose voluntary assisted dying as part of their end-of-life care, and the central concern driving that exclusion is capacity to make an informed choice as the condition progresses. These two studies do not resolve that concern. They do something narrower and, for a reader living with a diagnosis, possibly more useful: they document that the people at the centre of the argument have a settled, articulate, and largely unheard position on it.

For families, the practical reading is worth stating carefully. Nothing in either study changes what is legally available to anyone, in any Australian state or anywhere else. If you are living with dementia and the question of how your later care will be decided is keeping you awake, the tools that do exist now, advance care planning, an enduring guardian or attorney, a documented statement of what matters to you, are conversations for your treating clinician and, if you want one, a lawyer. What the research adds is a reason to have those conversations early and to expect to be taken seriously in them. The paper's own title is the plainest summary of its finding: "It should be my choice".

There is also a warning inside the data for anyone working in aged care. The participants were not primarily asking for a lethal prescription. They were describing a future they expect to be bad, in places they do not trust, among people they fear will stop listening. A request for assisted dying made out of fear of poor care is a statement about the care as much as about the dying. The researchers argue that people living with dementia can contribute to decisions about their own end of life when they are supported to do so. Thirty-six surveys and twelve interviews cannot settle a national law. They can, and should, settle the question of whether anybody bothered to ask.