Men who started playing American football at a younger age were rated by their families as more cognitively, behaviourally and psychiatrically impaired in later life, according to an analysis of 677 deceased male football players published online on 13 February 2026 in the Journal of Neurotrauma. The association held only among donors who died after age 60, and it persisted after adjustment for age at death, duration of play and neuropathology. Age of first exposure was not associated with chronic traumatic encephalopathy pathology, with other neurodegenerative disease pathology, or with a dementia diagnosis.
The donors came to the Understanding Neurologic Injury and Traumatic Encephalopathy (UNITE) Brain Bank, run through Boston University, from a starting pool of 1,079 donors; 399 with no football history and three women were excluded. Average age at death was 60.4 years and the average reported age of first exposure was 11.2 years. About three quarters (509) had played at college or professional level, and 471 (70 per cent) had CTE pathology at autopsy. Informants, usually family members, completed standardised scales of cognition, daily function, behaviour and mood; neuropathologists were blinded to the clinical histories. Among donors older than 60, each additional year before starting was associated with lower odds of cognitive composite impairment (odds ratio 0.897, 95 per cent confidence interval 0.814 to 0.988, p = 0.027) and with better cognitive, neurobehavioural and neuropsychiatric composite scores (all p values between 0.009 and 0.048). The authors, led by Sophia Nosek with Michael Alosco and Daniel Daneshvar as senior authors and including Ann McKee, describe the pattern as consistent with childhood head impacts reducing later resilience to pathology rather than causing more of it.
The wider literature is not settled. Grant Iverson and colleagues, surveying men aged 35 and over who had played high school football, reported in Frontiers in Neurology in May 2021 that earlier first exposure was not associated with worse depression or post-concussion symptom scores in middle and older age. The new paper's own authors say the age split may explain the disagreement: if effects surface only in the oldest players, studies of middle-aged men may miss them. They call for prospective, population-based studies of former players rather than further donor series.
Brain-bank samples are not random. Families donate, and often donate because something was wrong, so rates of impairment in this cohort are far higher than in the general population of former players: 79 per cent scored in the impaired range for apathy and 74 per cent for executive function. Start ages were reported retrospectively by informants, and the analysis was not pre-registered.